Connect with us

Daily News

Supreme Court Clear Doctor of Negligence in Maternal Death Case

A tragic event from December 2005 has recently come to a close in India’s Supreme Court.

Published

on

Supreme Court Clear Doctor of Negligence in Maternal Death Case
ChatGPT Generated (Not a Real Image)

A tragic case from December 2005 has finally ended with the Supreme Court clear doctor of negligence, bringing closure to a long legal fight. The case centered on 32-year-old Charanpreet Kaur, a lecturer and bank manager from Chandigarh, who was eight months pregnant when she entered Deep Nursing Home.

On December 22, 2005, Kaur delivered a baby boy at 2:40 am after being induced. Sadly, the newborn did not survive despite immediate efforts to revive him. Soon after, Kaur’s health collapsed due to postpartum hemorrhage, a major cause of maternal deaths in India. Doctors urgently requested blood and called specialists for help. They shifted her to PGI Chandigarh for advanced treatment, but she died by 5:30 am.

Her husband, Mattewal, accused the doctors of gross negligence. He said they mishandled her bleeding, failed to arrange a safe transfer, and kept poor medical records. In 2006, he filed a case before the Chandigarh State Consumer Commission seeking nearly ₹1 crore in damages.

In 2007, the State Commission agreed with him. It blamed the doctor for delaying the blood transfusion and for not confirming Kaur’s blood group. The Commission awarded ₹20.26 lakh as compensation. The doctor appealed, and in 2012, the case reached the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC). The NCDRC partly upheld the ruling and placed full blame on obstetrician-gynaecologist Dr. Kanwarjit Kochhar.

The Supreme Court has now overturned that decision. Justice Sanjay Kumar noted that five separate Medical Boards reviewed the case, and all found no negligence by Dr. Kochhar or the nursing home. He criticized the NCDRC for shifting focus to antenatal issues never raised in the original complaint.

The judgment also cited the Jacob Mathew vs. State of Punjab (2005) precedent. That ruling made clear that an unsuccessful medical outcome does not automatically prove negligence. Justice Kumar stressed that courts and consumer forums are not medical experts and must rely on medical evidence, not assumptions.

By allowing Dr. Kochhar’s appeal, the Supreme Court dismissed Mattewal’s complaint. The court ordered a refund of the ₹10 lakh already paid and directed his insurance and the Kochhars to split the amount. Each party will carry its own legal costs.

However, this outcome highlights the complexity of medical negligence cases in India. It shows that compassion must be balanced with evidence and that legal forums must respect medical expertise. In conclusion, the Supreme Court clear doctor of negligence stands as a reminder that justice must rest on facts, not emotions, even in deeply tragic situations.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Daily News

Woman has Passed Away After Brutal Marital Rape in Karachi

Published

on

Woman has Passed Away After Brutal Marital Rape in Karachi
ChatGPT Generated (Not a Real Image)

A 20-year-old, woman has passed away in Karachi after spending 20 days in a coma following a horrific case of marital rape and torture. Shanti, a young bride from Lyari, was attacked just two days after her wedding by her husband, Ashok Kumar. He brutally raped and mutilated her, leaving her intestines torn and her body severely injured. Despite medical efforts, she could not survive.

Shanti’s ordeal was made worse by the actions of her in-laws. Instead of helping, they silenced her, cut her off from her parents, and denied her urgent medical care. Reports reveal that they even attempted to erase evidence of the crime while asking her parents for forgiveness. Meanwhile, her working-class family struggled to raise funds for treatment but could not save her life.

Activists accuse doctors at Anklesaria Hospital, along with Dr. Rauf Shaikh, of covering up the crime. They allegedly sent her home despite her critical condition, preventing her from receiving the care she needed. Activists argue that this was not just negligence but part of a calculated attempt to protect the rapist and silence the victim.

The case has sparked outrage across Pakistan. Women’s rights groups are demanding justice, including the arrest of Ashok Kumar’s family, suspension of Anklesaria Hospital’s license, and an independent investigation into both the hospital and the in-laws. They insist society should not dismiss this crime as a “private, marital issue” but instead recognize it as sadistic torture.

Community leaders and activists stress that Shanti’s death is not an isolated case. Across Pakistan, women, children, and trans persons continue to face violence in the form of marital rape, domestic abuse, and systemic negligence. Many demand stronger laws against marital rape and stricter accountability for institutions that enable such crimes.

Shanti’s parents, devastated by the loss of their daughter, have taken her to their ancestral village, Sujawal, for burial. While Ashok Kumar remains in jail, activists emphasize that the fight is far from over. They vow to continue pressing for accountability and justice, not only for Shanti but for all survivors of rape culture.

In conclusion, the heartbreaking case where a 20 year old, woman has passed away reminds society of the urgent need to fight patriarchy, demand justice, and ensure no other woman suffers the same fate.

Continue Reading

Daily News

Chandigarh Police Arrest Five People for Carrying Charas

Recently, the Anti-Narcotics Task Force (ANTF) of Chandigarh Police made a significant arrest.

Published

on

Chandigarh Police Arrest Five People for Carrying Charas
ChatGPT Generated (Not a Real Image)

Recently, the Anti-Narcotics Task Force (ANTF) achieved a breakthrough as Chandigarh police arrest five people with 742 grams of charas worth ₹2.22 lakh. Shockingly, among those caught were three Punjab Secretariat employees, exposing a disturbing link between drug trafficking and government offices.

The operation unfolded on the night of September 7-8 after a tip-off about a car carrying narcotics from Himachal Pradesh to Chandigarh. Acting swiftly, police intercepted the vehicle around 3:15 AM at New Barricade Chowk. During the search, officers recovered 597 grams of charas and arrested four men on the spot.

One of them, Gaurav Kumar, a 35-year-old resident of Sector 7-B Chandigarh and a water carrier in the Punjab Secretariat, admitted to consuming charas. He revealed he sourced the drug from Kulwant Singh, a 35-year-old farmer from Mathla village in Shimla. Following this lead, police arrested Kulwant on September 9 in Parwanoo and seized another 145 grams of charas from him.

The other three accused, Abhishek, Ajay, and Amit Kumar, work as sweepers in the Punjab Secretariat. Like Gaurav, they were both users and sellers of charas. Their involvement raises serious questions about government staff participating in illegal activities.

Himachal Pradesh, known for its apple orchards, has also become a source of charas cultivation. Farmers like Kulwant mix farming with narcotics, making it easier for drugs to cross into Punjab. With Chandigarh located near the Himachal border, the region faces growing challenges in controlling the drug trade.

Law enforcement stresses that vigilance and quick action are key. Chandigarh Police continue dismantling drug networks and monitoring sensitive zones. At the same time, they urge citizens to remain alert and share information that could help prevent such crimes.

However, this case serves as a reminder that the drug problem affects every section of society, even government employees. The fight requires community support, awareness, and strong enforcement to protect future generations.

In conclusion, the arrest of these individuals shows the seriousness of the ongoing drug crisis. The Chandigarh police arrest five people case highlights the urgent need for vigilance, stronger border security, and community cooperation to keep the city safe.

Continue Reading

Daily News

Man Arrested for Cheating Woman of ₹10 Lakhs Promising a Job

In a recent incident, a man from Ludhiana has been accused of cheating a woman from Chandigarh out of ₹10 lakhs.

Published

on

Man Arrested for Cheating Woman of ₹10 Lakhs Promising a Job
ChatGPT Generated (Not a Real Image)

In a shocking case, a man arrested for cheating woman in Chandigarh after duping her of ₹10 lakh has raised concerns about rising fraud in the region. The victim, Saroj Bala from Manimajra, alleged that the accused, Ram Kishore from Ludhiana, tricked her with false promises of securing a government job for her son.

Saroj trusted Kishore because he claimed to have strong contacts in the Delhi Police. Believing his assurances, she paid him the money, only to be left disappointed when no job materialized. When she demanded the money back, he delayed repeatedly and eventually stopped responding.

According to police officials, Saroj filed her complaint once she realized the deceit. A case has been registered against Kishore under sections 406 and 420 of the Indian Penal Code, which deal with cheating and criminal breach of trust. The investigation is now underway.

This incident reflects the desperation many families face in Punjab. With an unemployment rate of around 8.5% in 2020, higher than the national average, job seekers often fall prey to fraudsters. Government jobs remain highly sought after because of stability and benefits, but dishonest individuals exploit these aspirations.

Punjab already faces a worrying backdrop, ranking 18th in India for corruption in 2021. Cases like this further highlight the importance of vigilance. Families must verify offers before paying money, as scams are becoming more common.

To protect themselves, experts advise job seekers to research offers thoroughly, avoid paying money without proper documentation, and consult trusted sources. If a promise sounds too good to be true, it likely is.

Community safety depends on awareness and timely reporting. Police continue urging people to report such scams immediately so others do not suffer the same fate.

In conclusion, while the desire for secure jobs remains strong, caution is vital. The case of Saroj Bala shows how fraud can happen to anyone. This man arrested for cheating woman stands as a reminder of the importance of awareness. And verification is key to protecting families from exploitation.

Continue Reading

Trending